By ESENDOM
June 16, 2025
Leer en español: Atrapados en el fuego: Comunidades dominicanas bajo la sombra de ICE
In the Heart of Dominican Neighborhoods, Migration Enforcement Brings Change and Uncertainty
Doña María's door in Washington Heights no longer opens like it used to. Where once children’s laughter filled the streets and bachata floated from apartment windows, a heavy quiet now hangs in the air. Conversations are hushed, glances cautious—many waiting, listening, for updates about “ICE.”
Across Dominican neighborhoods in the United States and its territories, immigration enforcement has become a central reality. For some, it’s a source of concern; for others, it’s a necessary part of upholding the law. What remains clear, however, is that the emotional and social impact is being felt deeply across communities with longstanding ties to both the U.S. and the Dominican Republic.
Puerto Rico: A Community on Alert
In San Juan’s Barrio Obrero, a historically Dominican neighborhood, daily rhythms have shifted. Local businesses see fewer customers. Church attendance has declined. Residents say the sense of normalcy that once defined the area has been disrupted.
“Now we have to carry our immigration documents at all times because you never know when you might get picked up,” said Digna Gómez, a legal resident interviewed by NPR. She described a neighborhood where enforcement is now part of everyday life.
Her neighbor, Juan Vega Paredes—nicknamed “the avocado man”—was detained earlier this year. Though he had no criminal record and was married to a U.S. citizen, he lacked legal status. He arrived in Puerto Rico in 2021 via a yola (a makeshift boat), and has worked in construction since. His case illustrates the challenges faced by many: people who may not pose a threat but remain vulnerable due to their undocumented status.
ICE reports that 75% of those arrested in Puerto Rico since 2021 have been Dominican nationals.
Legal Complexities: When Process and Policy Collide
Recent shifts in immigration enforcement strategy have generated both support and criticism. One notable change involves arresting individuals shortly after their immigration court cases are dismissed. While the intent is to improve efficiency and reduce backlogs, advocates argue it creates confusion and legal uncertainty—especially for those trying to follow the system's formal channels.
Immigration attorneys in cities like New York, Los Angeles, and Miami now advise clients to prepare for all scenarios, including detention at court appearances. The U.S. government has defended these actions as lawful and aligned with its duty to enforce immigration statutes.
Consular Response: Addressing Needs in Real Time
In response to these developments, Dominican consulates—particularly in major cities—have become increasingly active. In Los Angeles, Consul Alfonso Rodríguez reported no confirmed cases of Dominican nationals detained in recent operations, attributing that in part to the high number of long-term legal residents in the area.
Still, he expressed concern about isolated incidents of racial profiling, especially involving those who may not speak English fluently. The consulate has established a 24-hour hotline for families seeking information or assistance.
A National Reality
Beyond Puerto Rico and Washington Heights, the effects of enforcement are being felt in Dominican communities across the country. While public protests and advocacy campaigns have drawn attention to the emotional toll of immigration policy, many residents continue to quietly navigate a landscape of uncertainty.
Families are often separated. Individuals face difficult choices between self-reporting and avoiding public systems altogether. Children worry whether their parents will be home after school. Legal or not, the fear of miscommunication, misidentification, or sudden removal remains very real.
The Return Home: Integration Challenges in the Dominican Republic
The consequences of these policies also reverberate back to the island. The Dominican Republic has become one of the leading destinations for ICE deportation flights. On June 10 alone, 88 Dominican nationals were returned—many after serving criminal sentences or facing immigration violations.
These deportees often arrive without support networks, jobs, or housing. While some were involved in serious offenses, others have lived in the U.S. since childhood and find themselves estranged from their country of birth.
For the Dominican government and civil society, this raises ongoing questions about reintegration. Communities must now adapt to absorbing individuals who may speak little Spanish, lack local documentation, or face stigma due to their deportation status.
Conclusion: Between Enforcement and Displacement
The current wave of deportations targeting Dominican nationals reflects a broader reality of immigration enforcement: many individuals are being removed from the United States either for lacking legal status or after serving criminal sentences. While countries have the right to enforce their immigration laws and uphold public safety, the effects of these policies are not uniform—and for some, they come with deep, unintended consequences.
Many of those being deported today left the Dominican Republic as children, grew up within U.S. communities, and built lives shaped entirely by American culture and norms. For them, returning to the Dominican Republic is not a homecoming—it is a disorienting relocation to a country they barely know, often without support networks, job prospects, or the resources needed to reintegrate.
This disconnect creates lasting challenges, not only for the individuals but also for Dominican society, which is tasked with absorbing a population that is Dominican by birth but foreign in experience. As the country faces its own economic and social pressures, the reintegration of deportees remains a growing concern.
Ultimately, any meaningful conversation about immigration must recognize the complexity of these cases. Enforcement alone does not address the long-term questions of identity, belonging, and social reintegration. The challenge moving forward lies not just in determining who stays or who goes, but in understanding what happens next—and to whom the responsibility belongs.
Related:
Jim Carrey Denounces Trump’s Child Separation Policy
Council Member Ydanis Rodríguez is Arrested for Defending Immigrant Rights
De vuelta en las calles: los inmigrantes luchan en contra de ley racista en Arizona